Baked Potato on the Grill: Foil or Bare, and How Long

Foil does not make a grilled baked potato better. It makes a different potato: wrapped, it steams, giving soft, damp skin and a dense interior; bare, it bakes, giving a crisp, salty jacket and a fluffy middle. Both take about 45 to 75 minutes over indirect heat at 400 to 425°F, depending on size. This guide helps you choose between them, gives timing by potato size, shows how to tell when one is truly done, and covers the single food safety rule that matters with foil-wrapped potatoes, which most people never hear about.

Foil or Bare: Choose by the Skin You Want

  Wrapped in foil Bare, oiled and salted
Skin Soft, thin, a little wet Crisp, chewy, seasoned
Inside Moist, slightly dense Dry, fluffy, takes butter well
Holding Stays hot longer Cools faster; skin softens if held
Best for Cooking in the coals, crowds Steak night, loaded potatoes

A middle path works well: start the potatoes in foil for speed, then unwrap them for the last 15 minutes so the skin dries and crisps.

Prep the Potatoes While the Grill Heats

  1. Pick the right potato. Floury, high-starch types like russets or Maris Piper bake up fluffy. Waxy potatoes stay firm and creamy, which is better for potato salad than for a baked potato.
  2. Scrub and dry. Wet skin will not crisp.
  3. Prick each potato 4 or 5 times with a fork so steam can escape.
  4. For bare potatoes: rub with a teaspoon of oil and roll in coarse salt.
  5. For foil: oil and salt the same way, then wrap loosely, not tightly, in a single layer of foil.

Set Up the Grill for Indirect Heat

Direct flame burns the skin long before the centre cooks. Use a two-zone fire and put the potatoes on the cool side with the lid closed.

  • Gas: light the burners on one side, leave the other side off, and aim for about 400 to 425°F on the lid thermometer.
  • Charcoal: bank the lit coals to one side and place the potatoes opposite. Add a few fresh briquettes after 40 minutes for longer cooks.

Our guide to direct and indirect heat on the grill shows both layouts.

How Long by Size

Potato size Approximate weight Time at 400 to 425°F, indirect
Small 150 to 200 g 40 to 50 minutes
Medium 250 to 300 g 50 to 60 minutes
Large 350 to 450 g 60 to 75 minutes

Turn the potatoes once, halfway through, so the side facing the heat does not scorch. Opening the lid often, a cooler day, or a grill running below 400°F can easily add 15 to 20 minutes.

Worked example: steak night for four

You are grilling four 2.5 cm ribeyes and four medium russets. Put the potatoes on the indirect side 60 minutes before you want to eat. At 40 minutes, check them with a skewer and move them to the coolest corner. Sear the steaks over direct heat for the last 15 minutes while the potatoes finish, and everything lands together. Our steak grilling guide covers the steak side of the timing.

How to Tell It Is Done

  • Skewer test: a thin skewer or knife slides into the centre with no resistance at all.
  • Squeeze test: with an oven glove on, the potato gives easily when pressed.
  • Thermometer: a fluffy floury potato typically reads around 205 to 210°F in the middle. Below about 200°F the centre can still be waxy and firm.

Cut it open straight away. A slit along the top, then a push from both ends, lets steam out and stops the inside going gluey.

The Foil Rule That Matters: Unwrap Before You Store

This is the safety point most people miss. The UC Master Food Preservers’ fact sheet Baked Potatoes in Foil explains that foil-wrapped baked potatoes have been linked to rare outbreaks of botulism. The foil holds in moisture and keeps the potato in the 40 to 140°F danger zone, where bacteria can grow.

The fact sheet’s advice is simple:

  • Wrap loosely when cooking.
  • Remove the foil as soon as the potatoes come off the grill.
  • If they will not be eaten right away, refrigerate them without the foil.
  • Do not leave them at room temperature for more than 2 hours, or 1 hour if it is above 90°F.

Never leave leftover foil-wrapped potatoes sitting in a cooler, on the counter overnight or in a switched-off grill.

Toppings Worth the Effort

  • Butter, chives and flaky salt: the classic for a reason.
  • Sour cream, crisp bacon and sharp cheddar, melted on the grill for 2 minutes.
  • Leftover pulled pork or chopped brisket with a spoon of barbecue sauce.
  • Grilled corn, black beans, salsa and a little lime.

For the vegetables to cook alongside, our guide to which vegetables grill best covers prep and timing. If you have ever wondered whether soaking cut potatoes before cooking makes a difference, this explainer on what soaking potatoes really removes sorts fact from kitchen myth.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I cook potatoes directly in the coals?

Yes, if they are wrapped in two layers of foil and nestled at the edge of a bed of coals. Turn them every 10 to 15 minutes. Medium potatoes take about 40 to 50 minutes. The skin will char in places, which many people like. Unwrap them as soon as they are done, as with any foil-wrapped potato.

Should I microwave potatoes before grilling?

It is a useful shortcut. Microwave pricked potatoes for 4 to 6 minutes until they just start to give, then move them straight onto a 400°F grill for 15 to 20 minutes to crisp the skin. Do not part-cook them and then leave them standing before grilling; take them straight to the heat.

Can I grill sweet potatoes the same way?

Yes. Sweet potatoes follow similar timing at the same temperature, though very thick ones can take longer. They leak sugary juice as they cook, so set them on a sheet of foil or a small tray to stop it burning onto the grates. They are done when completely soft when squeezed.